top of page

IB K-12 or the hybrid IGCSE-IBDP system?

Writer: Gary Barker
Gary Barker
Nov 12
3 min read

The dangers of misconceptions and presumptive entanglement

​

Ever since I had the privilege of becoming an IB teacher, I have been a great proponent of the Diploma Programme; however, my appreciation of MYP as part of the continuity took a little longer.

​

teaching the geography tree to ib students on a whiteboard

My first experience of the IB programme was in a Portuguese school which taught the IGCSE-IB DP hybrid system, which I was convinced at that time was by far the best option. I came to this conclusion despite not actually having taught any IB classes, so this supposition was of course wholly subjective. 


I then had the opportunity to teach MYP I&S in South Korea, and any the scales of any notions of elitism immediately fell from my eyes. I did, however, still cling to my view that IGCSE students would have the content knowledge required for a head start over MYP students when it came to IB Diploma study. This was based on the presumption that MYP students would have little more than rudimentary geographical knowledge, as they would never have been taught geography as a separate subject. Coupled with the probability that MYP IB students would not have been taught by Geography specialists, convinced me the IGCSE-to-DP hybrid was the superior option.

​

While advising a Grade 9 I&S class on all the branches of humanities they could consider for their end-of-year projects, as a specialist I introduced many of the students to what geography actually is for the first time. The class, who were normally quietly enthusiastic, were suddenly buzzing and soaking up every word I said, asking me if they could photograph the board, while bombarding me with an endless barrage of questions about geographical subtopics. This experience only served to confirm my inherent bias that students would be far better off studying individual IGCSE humanities subjects before IB DP than MYP I&S. That said, I identified many definite positives I took from the MYP, and especially the regular incorporation of collaborative team projects into schemes of work and the ubiquitous use of rubrics with fully informed students.

​

In my next school, they employed my perceived ideal, i.e. the hybrid IGCSE leading on to IB DP, and my role was to teach both. It didn’t take long for me to realise once again many of my long-held presumptions were, of course, incorrect. To put it simply, I hadn’t factored in the nuance and interconnectivity of my subject, and how these are precisely the intellectual aspects that students struggle with when they move up from IGCSE to IB DP. I was now faced with the reality of students still writing IGCSE standard, for which they got A*s and As, being told that their essays would receive less than a third of the marks at DP level.


IB Diploma students shocked at their grades in the classroom

Some students were understandably resistant; after all, they’d sailed through their IGCSE Geography, and now the new guy is telling them they weren’t good enough (their perception and definitely not my intention). I then realised my first error of judgement - I hadn’t fully appreciated how fundamental to students' understanding of the requirements of the Diploma system rubrics are in MYP. In that system, rubrics explicitly detail, in plain language, what grade students are operating at, at every stage of a unit, and they self-assess, meaning there are no sudden shocks. In fact, when I taught MYP, I did not have any students misunderstand why they received the grades they did or attempt to convince me they deserved better, which I wish I could say was the case with my Diploma students at that time. The fact that my Diploma students did not have the benefits of the regular use of rubrics meant that the journey for some of them was considerably more difficult than it would otherwise have been.

​

Factoring in the collaborative nature of the MYP,  which builds in the necessity of co-operation, it instils the need to listen to and consider the views of others to make informed decisions leading to the creation of successful outcomes. In other words, it encourages thinking skills, and it removes subjectivity and replaces it with objectivity. An absolutely essential skill in understanding a complex and nuanced interconnected world. I still favour the hybrid approach, but experience has taught me that it is definitely not cut and dried and that there are very many merits and a few weaknesses in both systems.

​

As a footnote, having recently returned to teaching A-level, I noted the exam boards are now placing a much greater emphasis on synoptic examination questions, having obviously realised its value in the IB system. This is a great positive move on their part, but unfortunately this is placing new pressures on teachers and students, because the boards have yet to cut the required syllabus content to accommodate the new synoptic thinking skills required in any meaningful way.

Comments


bottom of page